Skip to content
GullySales

Customer acquisition and profitability modelling · Marketing

Before you grow a customer segment, you should know what it costs to win and what it leaves behind.

A distributor sells to small shops and to a few large chains. The chains bring the biggest invoices, but they ask for deep discounts, long credit and a visit from a senior salesperson each time. The shops cost little to serve and order again and again. Nobody has put the two side by side.

Scope, fee, reporting and term are agreed in writing after we have read your brief and spoken to you.

A marketer reviews acquisition performance charts

In one paragraph

Customer acquisition and profitability modelling builds a model, from your own figures, of what each customer segment costs to win and serve and what it returns. GullySales works out gross margin by segment, sales effort and channel cost, and writes down every assumption so your owner and accountant can challenge it.

That comparison is a model. It takes each segment, lists what it costs to win, what it costs to deliver and support, and what is left as gross profit. It also lists every assumption, such as how sales time was split and which overheads were shared, so the answer can be checked rather than believed.

This service compares segments to decide where to grow. If you want to analyse deals and products you have already sold, sales profitability analysis is the better fit. If your question is the cost of winning a customer through one channel, customer acquisition cost optimisation is closer.

Who it is for

This is written for you if these sound familiar.

  • Distributors and manufacturers choosing between large accounts, small accounts and different regions
  • Software and service firms deciding which kind of client to build the next sales effort around
  • Owner-led businesses with several customer types and one shared sales team
  • Clinics, schools and shops that serve different groups of buyers at different margins
  • Founders about to hire salespeople or raise marketing spend and unsure where it should go

Before you decide

When this may not be the right fit.

  • Your sales, costs and credit notes are not recorded anywhere. Bookkeeping has to come first.
  • You want a net profit statement, a tax view or a valuation. That is for your own accountant or adviser.
  • You want a forecast promising what a segment will earn. The model describes your own past figures and labels what is an estimate.

The problem

Does this sound like your business?

Common situations this work addresses.

  • “Our biggest customers do not seem to make us richer”

    Invoices are large, yet the money left at the end is small. Discounts, credit terms and delivery cost for those accounts are buried in the total.

  • “I do not know where to put the next salesperson”

    The hire is justified by revenue, not by what each segment costs to win. The new person may be pointed at the segment that is hardest to profit from.

  • “Every segment looks fine in the sales report”

    The report shows value and volume, not the sales time and support each segment consumes. A segment can top the chart and still drain the team.

  • “Our assumptions live in one head”

    The owner remembers how costs were split, and the spreadsheet does not say. A new finance hire cannot reproduce the figure, so nobody trusts it.

Choose the right scope

Start with the work your business needs.

  1. Large accounts against small accounts

    For an owner who suspects the biggest customers earn less than the small ones. The starting scope compares the two on gross margin, discount, credit and the sales time each takes.

  2. Where to point the next hire

    For a business about to add a salesperson or raise marketing spend. The model compares segments on cost to win and gross profit, so the new effort goes where it can pay back.

  3. New segment against existing ones

    For a firm considering a new customer type. We set the assumptions for the new segment beside your recorded figures for the old ones, and label every estimate as an estimate.

  4. Rebuild of an inherited spreadsheet

    For a business whose profitability sheet nobody can explain. We trace each number, write down the assumptions it hides and rebuild it so a new finance hire can follow it.

What we do

The work we can include.

Each deliverable and the purpose it serves. Your written scope confirms what is included, who is responsible, and what it costs.

  1. Segment definition sheet

    The segments to be compared, with the rule that places each customer in one of them. You approve it before any figure is shown, so the answer cannot be bent by how the lines were drawn.

  2. Assumptions register

    Every input and every judgement, each with its source, who supplied it and whether it is a recorded figure or an estimate. Your accountant can challenge any line.

  3. Gross margin by segment

    Invoices joined to product or delivery cost, net of discounts and credit notes. Returns and shared costs are treated by the written rules, and the unreconciled rows are listed.

  4. Sales effort allocation

    Quotations, visits, demonstrations and calls counted from your records where they exist, and from your sales lead's estimate where they do not. The two are labelled apart.

  5. Channel cost view

    Spend on advertising, directories, events, commissions and referral payments assigned to the segments they reached. Costs that cannot be assigned stay in a shared line.

  6. Cost-to-serve view

    Support, delivery, returns handling and account management effort per segment. It shows the segment that looks cheap to win and costs a great deal to keep.

  7. Segment comparison workbook

    One workbook with the segments side by side: what each costs to win, what it costs to serve, gross profit and cash timing. Formulas are visible and the sheet works without our help.

  8. Sensitivity notes

    A short set of what-if runs on the assumptions that matter most. They show which findings survive a different assumption and which do not.

How the result is measured

  • Gross margin by customer segment
  • Channel and sales cost to win a customer, by segment
  • Cost to serve by segment, labelled by source
  • Gross profit per customer after acquisition and service cost
  • Share of figures that are recorded rather than estimated
  • Assumptions changed after review, with the reason

Recorded as a baseline before work starts, so every later report has an honest comparison.

Marketing and sales together

Your sales lead receives a segment comparison to plan effort and discount around.

The handover shows which segments earn after the cost of winning and serving them, which assumptions carry the result, and which figures are still estimates. Your sales lead uses it to set where time and discount go, and records which segment each new opportunity belongs to. Pipeline value is not treated as profit; only completed orders and recorded costs count as results.

Decisions to make before the work starts

  1. Quality of the records

    The model is only as sound as the exports behind it. Mixed products, missing credit notes and unrecorded sales time mean more checking and more labelled estimates, and the written scope names what is usable.

  2. Accounting and tax questions

    Allocation of overheads and treatment of costs are judgements your accountant must accept. The model does not give accounting, tax or legal advice, and nothing in it replaces your adviser's view.

  3. Modelling, not implementation

    This service builds and explains the comparison. Repricing, new sales territories, CRM changes and campaign management are separate pieces of work agreed in writing. Updates after handover are included only if the scope says so.

This or a nearby service

Which piece of work fits your situation.

These services sit close to each other. The line between them, in plain words.

Sales profitability analysis
Choose sales profitability analysis when you want to see which products, customers, regions and salespeople leave profit after discounts, credit and returns. Choose customer acquisition and profitability modelling when the decision is which customer segment to grow, and what it costs to win and serve.
Customer acquisition cost optimisation
Choose customer acquisition cost optimisation when you want channel costs compared with the gross profit a paying customer brings, so the budget can move. Choose customer acquisition and profitability modelling when whole segments must be compared, including sales effort and cost to serve, before choosing where to grow.
Ideal customer profile development
Choose ideal customer profile development when you need to define which buyers are worth pursuing, using the customers you already serve. Choose customer acquisition and profitability modelling when the segments are chosen and you want to compare what each one costs to win and leaves behind.

A sample of the output

A segment comparison sheet sets the cost to win against what each segment leaves.

These illustrative rows are for a components maker. Each row is a customer segment, what it takes to win, what it takes to serve, and what remains. Estimates are marked so nobody reads them as results.

Illustrative example, not client data. Yours is built from your own records.
SegmentCost to winCost to serveWhat it leaves
Large factory accountsHeavy sales effort and site visitsDedicated account timeStrong gross margin once the first order lands
Small workshopsLight, mostly inbound enquiriesFrequent small orders and credit chasingThin after handling and credit costs
Distributor networkModerate, shared across the partner's customersLight, delivered in bulkMiddling after scheme payments to the partner
Online shop buyersPaid channel spend for each orderPacking, carriage and returnsDepends on how many orders come back
New regional segmentUnknown, marked as an estimateEstimated from similar accountsLabelled as an assumption, not a result

Before we start

What we need from you.

The work depends on these. Each says why it is needed and what happens when it is missing.

Sales and cost records by customer
The model rests on what each customer bought and what the goods cost you. Ledger exports or invoice sheets are acceptable if they reconcile. Without them there is no gross margin by segment, and the model cannot start.
Credit notes, returns and discounts
A segment that looks profitable on invoices can look different after reductions and returns. Share the records that show them. Without them, margins are overstated and the comparison favours segments that give the largest share back.
A fair estimate of sales team time
Sales effort is rarely recorded, so someone who knows the work must say how selling time divides between segments. A reasoned estimate is acceptable and will be labelled. Without it, cost to win is left blank.
Channel and marketing spend records
Cost to win includes what was paid to bring in each segment, such as advertising, events and agent fees. Share invoices or a spend sheet. Without them, acquisition cost is missing and segments look cheaper than they are.
A reviewer from your accounts side
An accountant or finance lead must be willing to challenge the assumptions register. Without a reviewer, assumptions go unchallenged, the model reflects one person's view, and your accountant meets the figures for the first time at handover.

How it works

How the work runs

The work itself, in order. How an engagement starts, from your brief to a written scope, is set out on our method page.

  1. 1

    Agree the decision and the segments

    After your requirements brief and a first conversation, we agree the decision the model serves, the segments to compare and the period. Scope, fee and term are set in writing.

  2. 2

    Collect and reconcile the records

    Your accountant exports sales, cost, credit notes and receipts. We check the totals against your books before building anything, and list what does not match.

  3. 3

    Write the assumptions and approve them

    We draft how costs, sales time and shared overheads are divided. Your owner, sales lead and accountant approve each rule before the comparison is run.

  4. 4

    Build the comparison and test it

    We build the segment workbook and run the sensitivity checks. Your accountant traces sample rows back to vouchers, and differences are resolved or recorded.

  5. 5

    Review the findings and hand over

    We walk through where each segment earns and where it does not. You decide what to do, and the workbook and assumptions register pass to the person who will keep them current.

Before you hire anyone

Do this first yourself.

Put your customers into three or four groups and see what you can already tell about each.

  1. List the customer groups you actually treat differently, such as large accounts, small accounts or regions.
  2. For each group, take last year's sales, discounts, credit notes and the cost of what was sold from your accounts.
  3. Ask your sales lead roughly how many quotations and visits each group takes.
  4. Write down which advertising, commission or event costs reached which group.
  5. Mark every figure as recorded or estimated before anyone draws a conclusion.

Judge any provider

What to ask any provider of this service.

Useful whoever you choose, including us.

  • How do you define a segment, and who approves the definition?
  • Where do you record each assumption, and can our accountant challenge it?
  • How do you separate recorded figures from estimates?
  • How do you treat shared overheads and sales time?
  • Can we update the model ourselves after handover?
  • What happens when our records have gaps?

Where this fits

Three pieces of sales work, in this order.

This work sits inside sales process design, at stage 0, foundation. The audit comes before it, and sales management keeps it running.

  1. Step 1

    Sales audit

    Find where deals are being lost and what to fix first.

    Start here if you cannot say where orders are lost.

  2. Step 2 · you are here

    Sales process design

    One written way to sell, from first enquiry to repeat order.

    Start here if every salesperson sells differently.

  3. Step 3

    Sales management

    A target, a review routine and someone who owns the number.

    Start here if the team has targets and no routine.

Tell us what you need Your brief is read before we call. Scope, fee and term in writing.

FAQ

Questions owners ask before they call.

Not here? More answers, or ask on WhatsApp.

How is this different from sales profitability analysis?
Sales profitability analysis looks at orders, products and accounts you have already sold, to see what earned and what did not. This service compares customer segments and adds the cost of winning them, so you can decide where to put effort next. The two can follow each other.
How is it different from customer acquisition cost optimisation?
Customer acquisition cost optimisation traces enquiries to paying customers and compares channels. This model looks across segments and sets cost to win beside cost to serve and gross profit. Where the channel question is the main one, that page is the better fit.
What if our records are incomplete?
The model uses what exists and marks what it estimates. A gap becomes an assumption in the register with a name against it, not a hidden guess. Some gaps may need to be closed before a finding can be relied on.
Will the model tell us which customers to drop?
No. It shows what each segment costs and returns on your own figures, with the assumptions beside it. Whether to reprice, serve differently or step back is your decision, taken with your accountant.
Can we update it ourselves afterwards?
Yes. The workbook uses visible formulas and the register explains each input, so your finance contact can refresh it with new exports. Any ongoing update by GullySales is agreed in the written scope.
What will it cost, and how do we begin?
Start with the requirements brief and a first conversation. The written proposal sets the scope, fee and term, and reporting arrangements are agreed at the same time. No figure is quoted before then.

Your next practical step

Tell us what you are trying to grow, and we will read it before we call.

Eight short steps, mostly taps. Skip anything you would rather answer on the call.