Commercial insurance brokers · Buyer persona
Write down who actually decides a mandate and what each person needs to hear.
A buyer persona for a commercial broker describes the finance head, promoter, CA or HR head involved in placing a business's cover, along with their worries and their part in the decision. GullySales builds these from your won and lost mandates so your messages speak to the right person.
Scope, fee, reporting and term are agreed in writing after we have read your brief and spoken to you.

What buyer persona means
A buyer persona is a plain description of the kind of customer who actually buys from you. It includes what they search, what worries them and who else they ask before deciding. GullySales builds this from real enquiries and past sales rather than a generic template, then uses it to write every page and advert.
Also for commercial insurance brokers
- Digital marketing for commercial insurance brokers
- Lead generation for commercial insurance brokers
- SEO for commercial insurance brokers
- Social media marketing for commercial insurance brokers
- Content marketing for commercial insurance brokers
- CRM for commercial insurance brokers
- Follow-up systems for commercial insurance brokers
- WhatsApp for commercial insurance brokers
Sales and marketing for commercial insurance brokers, the overview.
Last updated 14 Nov 2026. Rules for this trade differ by state and professional body, and they change. We describe restrictions in general terms, so check the current position with your own council or adviser before you publish anything.
For commercial insurance brokers
Where it usually goes wrong, and what we would do.
“The signer and the influencer are different people”
The promoter signs, the finance head compares, and the CA advises on whom to trust. A pitch aimed only at one of them misses the two whose objections decide the outcome.
“Each role fears something different”
A finance head worries about a rejected claim after a loss. An HR head buying group health worries about employee complaints. A promoter worries about cost and about being sold cover the business does not need.
“Industry changes the persona more than size does”
A cold chain operator, a hospital and a software firm each buy different covers for different reasons. A persona built per industry gives sharper messages than one for all corporate buyers.
“Lost mandates describe the persona best”
The reason a buyer gave for choosing someone else is a clearer portrait than any survey. Reading past pitches, won and lost, shows who actually objected and what they wanted answered.
What we do
What we deliver for commercial insurance brokers.
The work available for this need. We agree the deliverables and responsibilities for your engagement in writing.
Persona sheets per target industry
A one-page sheet for each industry showing the roles involved, their worries and the questions they ask.
Result: The team shares one picture of who they are talking to.
Won and lost mandate review
A structured look at your recent pitches and the reasons recorded for each outcome.
Result: Patterns in why you win or lose become visible.
Role-by-role message guide
The points that matter to a finance head, a promoter, a CA and an HR head, written separately.
Result: A single meeting can speak to each person present.
Objection and answer notes
The objections buyers raise, with honest answers your team agrees on.
Result: Placement staff answer consistently.
Persona-based qualification questions
Questions to ask at first contact that reveal who decides and who influences.
Result: You know whom to prepare for before the meeting.
How the result is measured
- Enquiry match to persona
- Conversion rate by persona
- Content aligned to persona
Recorded as a baseline before work starts, so every later report has an honest comparison.
Who is asking
Roles drawn from the mandates your firm has pursued, described without naming a client.
- A finance head whose claim dragged
- Wants to know who in your team handles claims and how a delayed settlement is escalated.
- A promoter buying cover for a new plant
- Wants to know whether you have placed a plant like theirs and what the insurer will inspect before it quotes.
- A CA recommending a broker
- Wants a firm that will not embarrass the recommendation, so asks how you handle queries and disagreements.
- An HR head renewing group health
- Wants to know who answers employee claim queries and how a rejected claim is followed up.
- An exporter after a cargo loss
- Wants to know how fast your team files and what proof of loss the insurer will ask for.
- A hospital administrator on professional indemnity
- Wants to know whether you understand clinical risk and which details the insurer reviews before agreeing terms.
Who it is for
This is written for these commercial insurance brokers.
- Small and mid-sized manufacturers with plant and machinery cover
- Exporters and importers needing marine cargo cover
- Real estate developers and contractors needing contractors' all-risk
- Hospitals and clinics needing professional indemnity
- IT and services firms needing cyber and professional liability
- Firms buying group health and group accident for staff
- Logistics operators and cold chains
- Hotels, malls and large retail premises
Before you decide
When this may not be the right fit.
- You have won no mandates and lost none yet, so there is no record to learn from and the personas would be guesses.
- Your team has not agreed who handles which buyer role, so describing the buyers would not change how anyone speaks to them.
Before you decide
Agree the work. Know how to judge it.
Buyer personas for commercial insurance brokers: use these checks to prepare, choose the scope, and review what changes.
Bring the right evidence
Write the decision the research must support, such as entering a market or choosing a buyer group. Separate what you know from sales records from what the team currently assumes.
Make the scope clear
Agree which buyers to speak to, which sources to review, and what access you can provide. Include lost enquiries and people who chose another supplier, where they are willing to take part.
Check the work in use
Look for source dates, sample limitations, and evidence that disagrees with the preferred answer. A recommendation should show how it follows from the findings.
Know when to change course
Do not treat a few positive conversations as proof of demand. Test the proposed offer with an actual buying decision before committing to a wider launch.
These are discussion points, not a fixed package. GullySales confirms the deliverables, responsibilities, fee, and term in writing after reading your brief and speaking with you.
Before we start
What to have ready before the work starts.
The records, access and decisions this work needs from commercial insurance brokers. Anything missing is noted in the written scope, with who will supply it.
- Pitch files for recent mandates
- Pitch decks, proposals and appointment letters for mandates you won, lost or never heard back on, with the client industry and the people involved. Personas are drawn from them. A rough folder will do. With too few, we build a first sketch and mark it thin.
- Names of buyers and advisers who will talk
- Four or five finance heads, promoters or chartered accountants, some who appointed you and some who did not, whom you are comfortable letting us ring. A short message from your director opens the way. Without these calls, the sheets rest on your team's recollection alone.
- A placement head's recollection of meetings
- An hour with the person who attends the pitches, to recall who asked about claims, who asked about price and who simply watched. No file records this. Their memory is the main source of how decisions were made, and without it the sheets lose their detail. Ask them to bring a recent pitch they remember well, so the recollection has a real meeting attached to it.
- Records of why mandates were lost
- Any note on why you lost a mandate: price, a relative as incumbent, a claims doubt, a lack of experience in the industry. The notes show where a role's worry went unanswered. If nothing was written, the director reconstructs a short list, and we treat it with caution.
- A view on the industries you want
- A statement from the owner of the industries and sizes of business you wish to win. The sheets concentrate on them. Without a view, we spread across every industry, and the sheets become too general to guide a pitch or a message.
How it works
How the buyer persona work runs
The work itself, in order. How an engagement starts, from your brief to a written scope, is set out on our method page.
- 1
Choose the industries and roles to describe
We start by choosing the two or three industries where you want more mandates and the roles that matter in each, such as the finance head, the promoter, the chartered accountant and the HR head. You decide which to study first. What exists afterwards is a short list of persona sheets to build, each tied to an industry and a role. We also note which of these roles your team has never met face to face, since those are the ones where our sheets will rest on the thinnest evidence.
- 2
Gather the files on mandates won and lost
We ask for the pitch files, appointment letters and notes on mandates you won or lost in those industries, and for what you remember of each meeting. You tell us who attended and who decided. The records show which questions came first, which worries returned and which pitches ended in silence, with names removed.
- 3
Talk to a few buyers and advisers
We choose a handful of finance heads, promoters or chartered accountants, some who appointed you and some who did not, and your director tells them we may call. We ask what they feared, who else was involved and what decided it. Notes are kept in their words. You hear the findings before anything is written.
- 4
Write a sheet for each role and industry
We write one sheet for each pairing, covering the role, the worries about cover, claims and cost of change, the questions asked and the proof needed. You read each for accuracy. Where a point rests on a single call, the sheet says so, and where files and calls disagree, we ask you which is right.
- 5
Test the sheets against live pitches
We lay each sheet beside your next few pitches and renewals and see whether the people behave as written. Your team corrects what is wrong. The sheets are then revised, and the qualification questions and the message guide for each role are drafted to match what that buyer needs to hear.
- 6
Compare appointments with the earlier record
After a period of use, we compare meetings, appointment letters and renewals with the record taken at the start, by industry and role. You tell us what your team noticed on calls. We decide together which sheets to rewrite, which to merge and where a new kind of buyer has appeared.
Where this fits
Three pieces of sales work, in this order.
This work sits inside sales process design, at stage 0, foundation. The audit comes before it, and sales management keeps it running.
Step 1
Sales audit
Find where deals are being lost and what to fix first.
Start here if you cannot say where orders are lost.
Step 2 · you are here
Sales process design
One written way to sell, from first enquiry to repeat order.
Start here if every salesperson sells differently.
Step 3
Sales management
A target, a review routine and someone who owns the number.
Start here if the team has targets and no routine.
FAQ
Questions owners ask before they call.
Not here? More answers, or ask on WhatsApp.
Do we need research with buyers?
How many personas should we have?
Will the personas change?
Can we use client names in a persona?
Is the chartered accountant a buyer or an influencer?
What if the promoter and the finance head want different things?
How much does it cost?
How long is the contract?
How soon will we see results?
Who will actually do the work?
More for commercial insurance brokers
Related work to consider.
Closest to this: strategy and research
Also for commercial insurance brokers
Or start from the overview: sales and marketing for commercial insurance brokers.
Your next practical step
Tell us what you are trying to grow, and we will read it before we call.
Eight short steps, mostly taps. Skip anything you would rather answer on the call.