Insurance agents and advisers · Sales competency assessment
Find out which agent explains exclusions well and which one skips them.
Sales competency assessment for an insurance agency checks each agent against the skills the role needs, using role plays, reviewed WhatsApp threads and observed meetings. GullySales writes the competency list, runs the exercises or trains your managers to run them, and hands back a gap sheet for every person.
Scope, fee, reporting and term are agreed in writing after we have read your brief and spoken to you.

What sales competency assessment means
Sales competency assessment checks each salesperson against the skills their role needs, using role plays, reviewed calls, manager observation and a self-assessment. GullySales writes the competency list, runs or trains your managers to run the exercises, and gives you a gap sheet for every person.
Also for insurance agents and advisers
- Consultative selling implementation for insurance agents
- Sales training needs assessment for insurance agencies
- Sales process for insurance agents and advisers
- Sales management for insurance agents and advisers
- Sales strategy for insurance agents and advisers
- Buyer personas for insurance agents
- CRM for insurance agents
- Follow-up systems for insurance agents
Sales and marketing for insurance agents and advisers, the overview.
Last updated 14 Nov 2026. Rules for this trade differ by state and professional body, and they change. We describe restrictions in general terms, so check the current position with your own council or adviser before you publish anything.
For insurance agents and advisers
Where it usually goes wrong, and what we would do.
“The agent with the biggest policy count is not always the best listener”
Sales totals reflect a good network as much as good selling. An agent with a large circle of relatives writes policies without ever practising discovery. Assessing what is done in the conversation, not only the policies written, shows who can sell to a stranger.
“Explaining a waiting period is a skill, not a script”
A family hearing about a pre-existing condition wait for the first time can feel misled. Some agents explain it plainly before the form is signed; others hurry past it. A rated role play with the same family scenario for each agent shows who does which.
“Self-ratings and observed work differ”
An agent who believes they follow up every renewal has left several unrecorded. Putting the agent's own rating beside the reviewer's evidence, line by line, starts a coaching conversation about facts instead of an argument about attitude.
“A POSP and a tied agent need different measures”
A person selling simple motor and health policies through a broker uses different skills from an agent advising on a long-term life plan or commercial cover. One generic scorecard marks the first as weak and the second as strong. Role-specific lists keep each judged on their own work.
What we do
What we deliver for insurance agents and advisers.
The work available for this need. We agree the deliverables and responsibilities for your engagement in writing.
Role competency list
The skills each role needs, written as things a person does in a meeting or on a call: asking about dependants, explaining exclusions, handling a premium comparison, agreeing the renewal step. You approve it against your strongest agents' work before anyone is rated.
Result: The list matches how your best agents actually sell.
Rating guide with your own examples
For each competency, a plain description of weak, acceptable and strong work, illustrated with situations from your agency, such as a family that has found a cheaper quote online.
Result: Two assessors rating the same call have the same words in front of them.
Role play scenarios
Fixed buyer cases with agreed objections: a salaried buyer asking about tax-saving cover, a family comparing premiums, a shop owner asking why fire cover costs what it does. Every agent plays the same case.
Result: Every agent has faced the same scenario, so the ratings can be compared.
Chat and call review sheet
A form for reading WhatsApp threads, quotes and call notes. Each rating points to a line in the conversation, with the agent's identity kept to the reviewer and the owner.
Result: Every rating can be traced to a line someone wrote or said.
Individual gap sheet
One page per agent: strengths, gaps, the evidence, and the practice suggested. A second page shows gaps common to the whole team.
Result: The owner can tell a team-wide gap from one person's gap.
How the result is measured
- Competencies rated with supporting evidence per rep
- Agreement between independent assessors
- Gap between self-rating and observed rating
Recorded as a baseline before work starts, so every later report has an honest comparison.
Who it is for
This is written for these insurance agents and advisers.
- Individual life insurance agents tied to insurers
- Health insurance agents and advisers
- General insurance agents for motor, home and travel cover
- Point of sales persons (POSP) working through a broker
- Corporate agents and small insurance agencies
- Insurance consultants advising on claims and portfolio reviews
- Agents focused on SME and commercial cover
- Family-run agencies handling second-generation clients
Before you decide
Agree the work. Know how to judge it.
Sales competency assessment for insurance agencies: use these checks to prepare, choose the scope, and review what changes.
Bring the right evidence
Bring real questions, objections, and call examples that the team finds difficult. Agree which selling behaviour needs to change and how it will be observed at work.
Make the scope clear
Choose the roles and situations to practise. Separate a training session from coaching, manager follow-up, and any scripts or reference material to be produced.
Check the work in use
Use a realistic practice conversation, then review the same skill in live work with appropriate permission. Look for a change in behaviour before attributing a sales result to training.
Know when to change course
If the problem is an unclear offer, missing product knowledge, or no permission to make a decision, fix that first. A communication workshop cannot remove those barriers.
These are discussion points, not a fixed package. GullySales confirms the deliverables, responsibilities, fee, and term in writing after reading your brief and speaking with you.
Before we start
What to have ready before the work starts.
The records, access and decisions this work needs from insurance agents and advisers. Anything missing is noted in the written scope, with who will supply it.
- The manager's account of the best and weakest agent
- Ask the manager to describe what the best agent does differently, without names. It starts the list. Without it, the list is generic. Describe a single behaviour, such as how the best agent opens a renewal call, since a specific detail gives the list its first true entry.
- Past lapse and lost-enquiry records
- Bring whatever shows which policies lapsed and which enquiries were lost. They help us pick role plays. Without them the exercises are invented. A rough note, such as the household's situation and the policy that lapsed, is enough.
- Agents' agreement to be observed
- Tell each agent what will be rated and what will not. Their agreement is needed for chat and call review. Without it, we use role plays only. Agents who know what is measured give more honest answers and are likelier to take part in good faith.
- Policy wordings agents must not misstate
- Provide the clauses that agents sometimes get wrong. They are used for role plays safely. Without them, we avoid product detail. A clause that is misstated in a role play and not corrected there becomes a clause that is misstated to a family.
- A promise about how the results are used
- The owner must decide whether results are used for support or for removal. State it before the first role play. Without this, agents guard their answers. State it plainly in one sentence, and the manager should be ready to repeat it when asked.
How it works
How the sales competency assessment work runs
The work itself, in order. How an engagement starts, from your brief to a written scope, is set out on our method page.
- 1
Write the list of what a good agent does
We sit with the manager and the best listeners in the agency and write what a good agent does in a meeting, on a renewal call and after a claim: asks about the household, explains an exclusion, calls without being chased. You edit it. What exists afterwards is a list in your own words, not a borrowed grid. We read the list back to you and ask whether your weakest agent would recognise it, because a list that nobody sees themselves in will not be used.
- 2
Separate the roles on that list
A POSP working through a broker, a tied agent and a corporate agent do different things, so we mark which items apply to which role. The manager approves. This stops one measure being used on everyone. Where an item applies only to those who can recommend a plan, we say so, so that a POSP is not marked down for something the broker's rules do not allow.
- 3
Collect examples of strong and weak work
You give us examples of a good explanation of a waiting period and a weak one, a renewal call handled well and one that lapsed. They become the rating guide. Names are removed, and no example is used in front of the agent concerned. We also ask for an example of an explanation that was correct but unclear, because correct and clear are different skills and the guide must say so.
- 4
Run role plays on real situations
Each agent takes part in two or three role plays built from your lost enquiries and claim moments, such as a spouse who asks about exclusions. The manager observes with the rating guide. Product details are checked beforehand so nobody misstates a clause in the exercise. Each role play ends with the agent saying what they would do differently, and the manager notes it before giving any rating.
- 5
Review a sample of chats and calls with consent
With each agent's agreement, we read a few real chats or call notes against the same guide. The agent also rates their own work first. Differences between the self-rating and the observed rating are noted. The agent sees the same sheet as the manager, so there is nothing hidden in the review.
- 6
Write the gap sheet and compare it to results
Each agent receives a sheet naming strengths and one or two gaps. We set these beside the renewals and lapses recorded before the work began. The manager decides what help each agent gets, and no result is promised. The gap sheet is written to be read by the agent, in plain sentences, with one example of work that met the standard.
Where this fits
Three pieces of sales work, in this order.
This work sits inside sales process design, at stage 1, prospecting and lead generation. The audit comes before it, and sales management keeps it running.
Step 1
Sales audit
Find where deals are being lost and what to fix first.
Start here if you cannot say where orders are lost.
Step 2 · you are here
Sales process design
One written way to sell, from first enquiry to repeat order.
Start here if every salesperson sells differently.
Step 3
Sales management
A target, a review routine and someone who owns the number.
Start here if the team has targets and no routine.
FAQ
Questions owners ask before they call.
Not here? More answers, or ask on WhatsApp.
Will the assessment be used to remove an agent?
Can the role plays include product details we must not misstate?
Will the assessment compare agents with each other?
Can we use this for a POSP who works through a broker?
How much does it cost?
How long is the contract?
How soon will we see results?
Who will actually do the work?
What do you need from us?
What if we are not happy with the work?
From the blog
Further reading for insurance agents and advisers.
6 min read · 12 Oct 2026Which fields a CRM for advisers, agents and loan consultants must haveThe twelve fields an adviser, agent or loan consultant needs in a CRM, what to leave out, and how to keep client data inside the consent the client gave.
5 min read · 6 Oct 2026How insurance agents keep renewals from lapsingRenewals lapse when nobody owns the date. Build a renewal register, make the call, and recover a policy that has already slipped.
6 min read · 6 Oct 2026How buyers decide which lender or adviser to trustPeople choosing a bank, lender, adviser or insurer start with a name someone gave them, then check you before calling. See what they look for.
More for insurance agents and advisers
Related work to consider.
Closest to this: sales craft
Also for insurance agents and advisers
Or start from the overview: sales and marketing for insurance agents and advisers.
Your next practical step
Tell us what you are trying to grow, and we will read it before we call.
Eight short steps, mostly taps. Skip anything you would rather answer on the call.