Skip to content
GullySales

Ad creative variations and retargeting creative design · Marketing

Your retargeting ads show one tired banner to everyone who left.

A shopper looks at a sofa, leaves, and then meets the same banner on every site for a fortnight. A buyer reads a pump page and later sees a generic brand advertisement that mentions neither the pump nor the question they asked. The ad reached the right person and said nothing relevant to them.

Scope, fee, reporting and term are agreed in writing after we have read your brief and spoken to you.

Marketers compare advertising layouts and campaign charts

In one paragraph

Ad creative variation and retargeting creative design is the making of a controlled family of ad artwork: one idea shown in several versions, plus follow-up artwork for people who have already visited your site. GullySales designs the versions, names each one, and hands over a variant matrix and production files so whoever runs your ads can test one change at a time.

Two jobs sit inside this page. Variation design makes several versions of one advertisement, each changing a single thing, so a result can be traced to a cause. Retargeting design makes artwork for people at a known point, such as a viewed product, an abandoned form or a lapsed enquiry.

GullySales designs the artwork only. Writing the lines, buying the media, setting audiences and reading the results belong to other scopes, and the related pages show where each one sits. The pieces are built to be handed to whoever runs your campaigns.

Who it is for

This is written for you if these sound familiar.

  • A shop or online store whose retargeting banner is the same for every visitor
  • A software firm that wants one demo advertisement shown to a buyer, a user and a lapsed trial
  • A clinic or hospital that runs one advertisement per service and cannot tell which look is working
  • A factory or distributor whose product ads are a single image resized for every placement
  • A school or college that needs a fresh set of artwork for each intake without a redesign
  • A restaurant or salon that wants offer ads and reminder ads to look like the same business

Before you decide

When this may not be the right fit.

  • You need the campaign itself set up, audiences built and budgets managed. Retargeting and remarketing runs the channel; this page supplies only the artwork it shows.
  • You want a first batch of ad concepts across formats for a new product. Performance advertising creatives develops directions and tests them, and the variation work here can follow it.
  • You need the lines of copy tested against each other. Ad copy variation and headline testing writes the words, and the two scopes can be bought together.

The problem

Does this sound like your business?

Common situations this work addresses.

  • “Every returning visitor sees the same advertisement”

    A person who viewed a price list, a person who abandoned a form and a person who bought last month all meet one banner. None of them is spoken to, and the repeat view starts to feel like pestering.

  • “We changed five things and cannot say which one worked”

    When a new version swaps the picture, the headline, the colour and the button together, a better result teaches nothing. The business cannot repeat the win because it never learned the cause.

  • “The resized versions look cropped and careless”

    One master image stretched into every shape cuts off the product, the price tag or the button. The placement that matters to the buyer gets the worst crop, and the advertiser never sees it.

  • “Nobody can find the version that ran last quarter”

    Files sit in chat threads under names such as final and final two. When a version needs to run again, or be explained to a new agency, the team rebuilds it from a screenshot.

Choose the right scope

Start with the work your business needs.

  1. One idea in a set of versions

    A single approved layout drawn in a handful of versions, each changing one element, with the matrix that names them. Bought when a campaign is about to start and the business wants its first test to teach something.

  2. A retargeting set for each stage

    Artwork for viewed, started, abandoned and lapsed visitors, drawn as one visual family. Bought when the campaign already exists but every returning visitor sees the same advertisement.

  3. A refresh of advertising that has tired

    New versions drawn from the existing master, keeping what recorded results favoured and replacing what did not. Bought when the same artwork has run for a long time and the audience has stopped noticing it.

  4. A version for a second audience

    The same idea redrawn for another buyer, such as a parent instead of a student, or a procurement manager instead of a user. Bought when one set of ads is asked to speak to two kinds of reader.

What we do

The work we can include.

Each deliverable and the purpose it serves. Your written scope confirms what is included, who is responsible, and what it costs.

  1. Master creative idea and layout

    One approved layout that carries the idea: image area, message area, offer area and button. It fixes what stays constant across every version, so differences between versions are deliberate and not accidents of resizing.

  2. Variant matrix

    A table naming every version, the single element it changes, and the question it is meant to answer. Whoever manages your advertising can run the versions as a clean test and read results against a named change.

  3. Version set for the agreed placements

    Each version drawn for the placements you agreed, using the platform's current specification. Safe areas, crops and text positions are set for each shape, not left to automatic resizing.

  4. Retargeting stage artwork

    Separate artwork for the points you choose: viewed a product, started an enquiry, abandoned a booking, lapsed customer. Each stage speaks to what the person did, in the same visual family as the first advertisement.

  5. Exclusion and reminder-ending artwork

    A closing version for people who have already bought or enquired, and a gentle final reminder for those who have seen the message enough. It prevents a customer being shown an offer they have already taken.

  6. Naming convention and file handover list

    Every file named by idea, stage, element changed and placement, with a list of what was handed over and in which format. Anyone on your team can find a version again without asking.

  7. Editable source files

    The working files with layers, linked images and fonts listed with their licence notes, so a later change to a price tag or a button is made on the original and not rebuilt from an exported image.

How the result is measured

  • Versions in the matrix with exactly one element changed
  • Placements with artwork drawn specifically for them
  • Retargeting stages that have their own artwork
  • Files found by name without asking the designer
  • Platform rejections on upload
  • Enquiries or orders recorded against each named version

Recorded as a baseline before work starts, so every later report has an honest comparison.

Marketing and sales together

The salesperson who takes the enquiry needs to know which advertisement was seen.

Whoever answers the enquiry, whether a salesperson, a shop counter or a clinic front desk, asks what the person saw and records the version name from the matrix. Those records connect an enquiry or order to one named change, and they show your advertising manager which artwork brings people worth calling back.

Decisions to make before the work starts

  1. What is not included

    The words, the campaign build, the audiences, the media budget, the tracking set-up, the reading of results and the landing page are separate scopes. Printing and publishing are not part of this work. Where the partner pages exist, they can be scoped together.

  2. What stays your decision

    Offers, prices, product claims, testimonials, legal lines and trade mark checks are yours to approve. We design the space for them and leave the content to you. If a claim cannot be supported in your own records, it does not go into the artwork.

  3. Where a platform or regulator sets the rules

    Each advertising platform publishes its own current specification and policy, and rejects artwork that breaks them. Health, finance, education, property and food advertising also answer to the rules of the relevant regulator, council or adviser, who decides the wording and declarations.

This or a nearby service

Which piece of work fits your situation.

These services sit close to each other. The line between them, in plain words.

Retargeting and remarketing
Choose retargeting and remarketing when the audiences, tracking, budget and exclusions need building and managing as a channel. Choose this service when that campaign exists or is planned and the missing piece is the artwork each stage of returning visitor should see.
Performance advertising creatives
Choose performance advertising creatives when you need new creative directions across several formats and a plan to compare them with results. Choose this service when the direction is already chosen and the work is drawing controlled versions and stage artwork from it.
Facebook and Instagram ad creative design
Choose Meta ad creative design when you need one set of artwork built for Facebook and Instagram placements. Choose this service when the need is the matrix of versions and the follow-up artwork for returning visitors, whichever platforms the campaign runs on.

A sample of the output

A variant matrix says what each version changes and what it is meant to answer.

This is part of a matrix for an illustrative furniture shop. Each row is one version of the same advertisement. Read across to see the single element changed, the question behind it and the stage of visitor it is shown to.

Illustrative example, not client data. Yours is built from your own records.
Version nameElement changedQuestion it answersShown to
Master sofa advertNothing, this is the referenceWhat does the plain layout achieve on its ownPeople new to the shop
Sofa with room photographProduct cut-out replaced by a roomDo buyers respond to seeing the sofa in a homePeople new to the shop
Sofa with delivery lineButton wording replaced by a delivery messageDoes a delivery reassurance move people to enquirePeople who viewed a sofa page
Sofa with colour choicesSingle product shown in several fabric coloursDo buyers want to see the range of fabricsPeople who viewed a sofa page
Sofa reminder endingOffer line replaced by a gentle reminderDoes a quieter close stop the repeat views feeling pushyPeople who left without enquiring

Before we start

What we need from you.

The work depends on these. Each says why it is needed and what happens when it is missing.

The advertisements already running
Exported copies of current versions and the placements they use. They show what the audience has already seen, so new versions are not repeats. Without them, the first test may rediscover a result you already have.
A named person who runs the campaigns
The matrix must match how the campaign is built, so we need to speak to whoever manages the audiences and budgets. If nobody does, the versions are drawn correctly but cannot be run as a clean test.
A list of visitor stages worth separating
Decide which behaviours deserve their own artwork, such as viewed, started, abandoned or lapsed. Each stage added is another family of files. An unclear list leads to artwork nobody is able to attach to an audience.
Approved offers and claims in writing
Offer lines, product claims and legal wording must be settled before artwork is final. Where they are still being argued, we draw placeholders and hold the finished versions back, which delays handover.
Brand colours, fonts and logo files
The master depends on your logo and brand rules. If these are not fixed, we set the artwork in a provisional style and warn you that a later brand change will mean redrawing every version.

How it works

How the work runs

The work itself, in order. How an engagement starts, from your brief to a written scope, is set out on our method page.

  1. 1

    Read the brief and the advertising so far

    We read your brief and look at the advertisements already running, the placements in use and what your advertising manager has noticed. We note which versions exist and which were never recorded, so nothing is designed twice.

  2. 2

    Agree the audience stages and the one question

    With you and whoever runs the campaigns, we list the stages that need their own artwork and the single question each test should answer. A test that tries to answer everything at once is cut down here.

  3. 3

    Design the master and fix what stays constant

    We draw the master layout and settle logo position, colour roles, type and button style. The master is approved before any version is drawn, because every difference later must come from a choice and not a drift.

  4. 4

    Draw the versions, one change at a time

    Each version alters one element: the picture, the offer line, the button wording, the colour of the call to action. We keep a record of what changed so the matrix is accurate when it is handed over.

  5. 5

    Adapt each version to every placement

    We redraw, not just resize, for each shape you agreed, then check text sits clear of platform interface elements and crops. A phone feed and a desktop sidebar are looked at on their own.

  6. 6

    Hand over files and walk the team through them

    We deliver the matrix, the named files and the sources, then walk your team and your advertising manager through how to read the versions. Anything the platform rejects on upload is corrected as the written scope says.

Before you hire anyone

Do this first yourself.

Look at your own advertising from the point of view of someone who has already visited your site.

  1. Open your website in a private window, visit one product or service page, then leave and note which advertisements follow you.
  2. List every version of your current advertisement and write beside each the one thing that differs from the others.
  3. Group your returning visitors by what they did last, such as viewed, started a form or bought, and write the groups down.
  4. Find the original files for your best-known advertisement and check you can open and edit them.
  5. Name the person who approves offers and claims, and the person who sets up the audiences.

Judge any provider

What to ask any provider of this service.

Useful whoever you choose, including us.

  • Will every version change only one element, and will I receive a matrix that says which?
  • Do you redraw for each placement or resize one master, and can I see an example of both?
  • How will you design the follow-up artwork for people who have already bought or enquired?
  • What do I receive at handover: source files, a naming system and a list of fonts and image licences?
  • Who is responsible when the platform rejects a version, and what does the written scope say about fixing it?

Where this fits

Three pieces of sales work, in this order.

This work sits inside sales process design, at stage 1, prospecting and lead generation. The audit comes before it, and sales management keeps it running.

  1. Step 1

    Sales audit

    Find where deals are being lost and what to fix first.

    Start here if you cannot say where orders are lost.

  2. Step 2 · you are here

    Sales process design

    One written way to sell, from first enquiry to repeat order.

    Start here if every salesperson sells differently.

  3. Step 3

    Sales management

    A target, a review routine and someone who owns the number.

    Start here if the team has targets and no routine.

Tell us what you need Your brief is read before we call. Scope, fee and term in writing.

FAQ

Questions owners ask before they call.

Not here? More answers, or ask on WhatsApp.

Who owns the finished artwork and the source files?
The written scope sets out ownership, licences, changes and fees for the artwork and the editable files. We list which fonts and images inside the work are licensed to you and which are not, so you know before the next campaign what can be reused.
How many versions should one idea have?
That depends on the question you want answered and on how much traffic your campaign receives, which your advertising manager knows. We agree the list of versions in the written scope, and a short list that tests one change cleanly is better than a long one that tests nothing.
How are changes handled after the first versions are shown?
Changes are handled as the written scope says, agreed before the work starts. We record each change against the matrix, so the version history stays accurate. A change to the master touches every version, and we say so before making it.
Do you write the headlines and offer lines?
Not in this scope. We design with the words you supply, or with copy bought separately, such as ad copy variation and headline testing. We can set placeholder lines to show the layout, but you approve every claim and price before anything runs.
Can you promise that the new versions will improve results?
No. Results depend on the audience, the offer, the budget, the platform and the landing page, as well as the artwork. We promise a clear matrix and clean files, so that whatever result comes can be traced to a named change.
How do offers, prices and claims get approved?
You approve every offer, price, product claim and legal line before artwork is finalised. For health, finance, education, property and food, your own council, regulator or adviser decides the wording and any declarations, and the platform's advertising policy sets its own limits.

Your next practical step

Tell us what you are trying to grow, and we will read it before we call.

Eight short steps, mostly taps. Skip anything you would rather answer on the call.